Commentary: Sia fans should say see ya later after ‘Music’
New movie ‘Music’ blasted as ableist and inaccurately portraying the Autism community
Terrible.
If I were to put ‘Music’, a film directed and co-written by recording artist Sia, into one word, it would be terrible.
As my sister has Down syndrome, I believe strongly that the special needs community needs more attention.
But not like this.
The project included neurotypical actor Maddie Ziegler playing the autistic main character, Music, as well as techniques that are a danger to those with special needs, resulting in an uproar of anger with the Autism community for representing them in a disgusting way.
The opening scene acts as the first taste of insensitivity.
Music is shown wearing black face and terribly imitating stimming, behavior marked by repetitive physical actions or movements. These behaviors are found mostly in civilians on the Autism spectrum, and the scene infuriated people of color as well as the poorly described Autism community.
Music is never shown speaking outside of a few words and sentences, with her wide, grinning mouth and completely exaggerated facial expressions. The blatant mockery and imitation of Autism disgusted me to no end.
To add wood to the fire, the strobe lights and colors displayed throughout the dancing scenes has overstimulated many in the special needs community. Without any warning regarding the flashes, or removing of the flashes entirely, it has been incredibly dangerous for the community the movie was made for.
Moving onto another portion of the movie, Music is shown having a meltdown, continuously hitting her head and destroying anything in her path.
Seconds later the main characters, Zu and Ebo, jump into action. Music is seen held in a prone restraint.
Prone restraint, or restraining by applying physical pressure to a face-down person, is incredibly dangerous and has killed thousands of people with special needs at the hands of uneducated civilians.
A little over three years ago in El Dorado, California, a 13 year-old boy lost his life in a now-closed school after being held in a prone restraint.
Another instance of the deadly grip is the infamous death of George Floyd, who was held in the same restraint for around nine minutes.
After viewing the threat of both the prone restraint shown in the movie and the sensory issues, I believe this movie is putting its audience in major harm and offending the special needs community in the process.
Although her intentions were pure, Sia has butchered this movie. And with a 10 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, I am not the only one feeling this way.
For not only me, “Music” has been a terrible way of representing Autism. Consisting of mockery, blackface, prone restraint and dangerous flashes, the movie has disgusted me.
Katherine is a junior and Editor of the Entertainment section. This is her third year on the Gazette staff.
lizzy • Mar 5, 2021 at 10:36 am
i agree. i think this movie is disgusting. in my opinion sia made this movie primarily for the money, not to spread awareness. but i think this article was very well written. good job 🙂
Sarah Alami • Mar 5, 2021 at 7:52 am
Thank you for such an informative article. I have not watched it yet, but I really have no interest in doing so after reading what you had to say. I think it is pretty tone-deaf of Sia, and I think she needs to be extra careful when creating movies portraying any person on the spectrum. She should of done her research before and made sure that she wasn’t sending something out to the world that could cause so much harm.
Lee Randolph • Feb 28, 2021 at 9:45 am
Great article! After watching just the opening scenes I was disgusted at how autistic (yes I said autistic, most autistic people prefer that over “person with autism”) people were portrayed. The rigid movements make a mockery of stemming. Sia claimed to work with Autism Speaks which is notorious for belittling and ignoring autistic voices. The use of AAC through the movie is also horribly portrayed, the most Music says is “I’m happy” or “I’m sad” when in reality AAC devices are very complicated and great at communication. Non-verbal autistic people can understand and process everything, they just might not respond in the way most people do. Overall this is a disgusting movie and Sia should be ashamed to have her name on it.
Ethan Shea • Feb 26, 2021 at 10:37 am
Thank you for this informational article! I will not be watching this movie after what I have read.
allison • Feb 26, 2021 at 10:37 am
i love this, i agree with what you are saying!
Diana Al Attraqchi • Feb 26, 2021 at 10:37 am
This is a very nicely written article. You talked about the movie and how you felt about the it in a very detailed way.
ria • Feb 26, 2021 at 10:35 am
I think this article was very well written and explained the movie well. It would also be helpful, though, if you included how Maddie felt while filming this movie because she was very uncomfortable portraying this role and it could seem like it was her fault too, but Sia should be the one to take credit for this disgusting movie.
Barbara Donovan • Feb 26, 2021 at 10:34 am
I have not seen this movie. I believe it is essential to speak about Autism and be educated about it. However, it sounds like this movie was a big flop. I would still like to see this movie for myself, but I don’t think I’m going to like it.
cailee • Feb 26, 2021 at 10:33 am
Great article! I have not seen this movie yet but from how you described it, it sounds hurtful and unnecessary. I can’t believe a big artist like Sia would put something out there like this. It may be just for a movie but they don’t understand that that movie is offensive and hurtful to many people.
Sharvani • Feb 26, 2021 at 7:54 am
This was a very well written article. The representation in the movie was so poor, and its disturbing that Sia chose to release it.
William Armour • Feb 26, 2021 at 7:53 am
This news is horrible! It honestly surprises me how much Sia messed this up. Has she never met a person suffering from autism or down syndrome?
Eniola Okon • Feb 26, 2021 at 7:53 am
I really liked how your opinion was expressed in this article! I definitely agree, though, that this movie was an outrage. I watched ‘Music’ with my family members, my 10-year old brother (who is on the Autism spectrum) leaving almost immediately. I am sure that the intentions of this movie were adequate, but the end result was terrifying and offensive. From firstly not casting someone who IS on the spectrum to lastly making the movie so difficult and embarrassing to watch, including controversial perspectives of several sensitive topics…I agree that this movie was terrible.
ava casagrande • Feb 26, 2021 at 7:53 am
I have not seen the movie and after reading I don’t think I want to. Even if the idea that Sia was trying to put out was pure, it sounds like she really messed up and that will most likely drag her name down. Maybe if she had done more research or something the movie could have been pure and good but who knows. This article was good, and actually very helpful maybe to people who don’t know a lot about autism and what can be problematic!
ciana • Feb 26, 2021 at 7:53 am
great work expressing how hurtful this movie is. good job on the article!